移动通信网 程然
在 TIP Fyuz 2026 大会的一场专题讨论上,通感一体化(ISAC)与 AI 原生网络成为焦点议题。与会专家的共识相当明确:ISAC 有望将移动网络升级为类似雷达的感知系统,用于探测无人机等目标物体,而 AI 则是把原始感知数据转化为决策的关键环节。不过,摆在运营商面前的现实难题同样突出——如何部署、如何收费、如何让这项能力真正成为新的收入来源,目前仍无定论。美国国防部(DoW)FutureG 项目高级技术顾问 Scott Fox 直言,需求端尤其是国防与公共安全领域的诉求清晰而迫切,但商业化路径依然悬而未决。
国防需求牵引:商用网络的可扩展性诱惑
美国国防部正在通过 FutureG 计划为早期研发注入资金。Fox 解释了军方押注运营商网络的原因:传统军用装备“设计精密、性能出色,但无法规模化,且维护难度大”。而由运营商运营的 ISAC 网络可以提供“分层防御体系,能够提示并引导更高层级、更专用的能力”,这种覆盖水平是国防部自建网络难以负担的。就在上周,国家频谱联盟与 DoW FutureG 办公室宣布在 RAPID 计划框架下向 11 个团队发放总额超 5000 万美元的资助,参与方近 30 家企业和高校,AT&T 与爱立信均在其列。不过 Fox 强调,国防部的立场是“移动网络运营商需要自己找到用例”。
AI 的角色在这场讨论中被反复提及。Fox 的判断颇为直白:“我们认为没有 AI 就不可能实现 ISAC。”但他同时指出,AI 也是 ISAC 面临的最大风险来源,底层安全隐患不容忽视。是德科技无线战略与行业合作副总裁 Kalyan Sundhar 则从工程角度描绘了复杂度:感知功能“给许多环节都添了乱”,工程师不仅要建模链路,还要建模环境本身,包括建筑物的反射以及被追踪的无人机或机器人,并需要在规模化场景下持续修正模型。
【关键数据】
- RAPID 计划资助: 超 5000 万美元,覆盖 11 个团队、近 30 家参与方
- 北向暴露 API 定义进度: 约 75%,规范预计 3 月发布
- 美国运营商在网 ADC 数量: 约 3500 万个,设备侧数亿个
- 人工干预削减幅度: 仿真环境下降幅最高 30%

技术障碍:波形、同步与仰角难题
AT&T 技术团队高级首席成员 Shahram Mohajeri 介绍了几个月前在得克萨斯州与爱立信联合完成的演示:多基地感知成功定位并追踪了多架无人机,一套为通信而生的系统干起了雷达的活,现场部署的 AI 负责滤除杂波。但他坦言“这需要消耗大量资源”,将其转化为新收入来源“需要非常审慎地研究”。Parallel Wireless CEO Steve Papa 补充了另一层挑战:多基地感知虽然降低了单节点成本,却让时序同步变得至关重要,该公司正尝试构建首个纳秒级同步的站点集群。此外,蜂窝天线普遍下倾朝地,“向上看”无人机与“向下看”地面目标是两类截然不同的问题。波形层面,Fox 指出 OFDM 在高移动性、高多普勒条件下会出现“致盲”,国防部正在资助 Cohere Technologies 测试替代方案。
并非所有声音都主张激进重构。Tiami Networks CEO Amitav Mukherjee 建议保持克制:“利用环境中已有的能量。”在他看来,基于 OFDM 的感知完全可以充当早期预警系统,需要更高精度时再引入其他传感器。这种渐进路线与 Papa 的激进立场形成了鲜明对照——后者甚至对标准化进程提出批评:“我们不能指望 3GPP 把这件事做对。”标准层面,Mohajeri 澄清了现状:ISAC 已在 5G-Advanced 中获得使能,北向暴露 API 约完成 75% 的定义,规范预计 3 月发布,同时 ISAC 也将成为 3GPP 6G 规范的关键组成部分。
变现路径:自动驾驶系统是最快出口
在变现路径上,Mukherjee 给出了明确判断:将 ISAC 与自动驾驶系统绑定是最快的营收路径,“你不能等着人类介入,再告诉配送无人机该往哪里飞”。其公司平台被定义为一个多模态世界基础模型,能够检测变化并预测事件,瞄准配送机器人与无人机编队——在这一场景中,每一次人工干预都直接侵蚀运营商的利润。仿真结果显示,该平台可将干预次数或干预时间削减至多 30%。Sundhar 做出了类似论证:微多普勒变化与轨迹数据可以喂给模型,预测目标的下一步动作。硬件基础同样可观,据 Papa 统计,美国运营商的无线设备中约有 3500 万个模数转换器(ADC)在网运行,具备频谱感知潜力,设备侧数量更达数亿级。Mukherjee 补充称:“这些额外的 ADC 完全可以用于感知。”
从架构角度,Mohajeri 梳理了运营商提供服务所需的拼图:一个负责请求鉴权的暴露层、部署在分组核心网中的全新感知功能——将每个请求转化为对相应无线设备的指令,还需要决策感知服务是否常开,因为感知会挤占通信容量,漫游以及非本网用户的感知规则同样待解。综合来看,ISAC 的技术验证已经取得阶段性成果,资金、标准和产业链协同都在加速,但从演示走向可计费的商用服务,运营商仍需在资源开销、商业模式与监管边界之间找到平衡点。谁能率先跑通“感知即服务”的闭环,谁就有望在 6G 时代占据先手。
出处:Feature: Why ISAC needs AI, operators to reach market lift-off
英文原文Integrated sensing and communications (ISAC) promises to turn mobile networks into radar-like sensors which detect drones and other objects, with AI turning raw sensing into decisions, but operators still need to find to way to monetise it. The need is clear, particularly for defence and public safety, but how operators will deploy and sell the capability is still unresolved, according to a panel at TIP Fyuz 2026 on ISAC and AI-native networks. The US Department of War (DoW) is putting money into early work through its FutureG programme, said senior technical advisor Scott Fox ( pictured, second from left ), among other reasons because it wants commercial technology which scales. “We design really exotic, very sophisticated equipment that’s really good, but it doesn’t scale, it’s hard to support,” he said. Operator-run ISAC would give it “a tiered defence that could tip and cue to higher, more exotic-type capabilities,” at a level of coverage the department could not afford to build itself. Last week, the National Spectrum Consortium and the DoW’s FutureG Office announced more than $50 million in awards to 11 teams under the RAPID programme, involving nearly 30 companies and universities, including AT&T and Ericsson. But in the department’s view, Fox said, it is “expected that mobile network operators need to find their own use cases”. “We don’t believe ISAC is possible without AI,” Fox said, adding AI also poses the greatest risk to it, pointing to underlying threats. Challenges Kalyan Sundhar ( pictured, fourth from left ), VP and GM of wireless strategy and industry partnerships at Keysight, said sensing “throws a wrench into a lot of things.” Engineers need to model the environment as well as the link, including reflections off buildings and the drones or robots being tracked, and then refine those models at scale. Shahram Mohajeri ( pictured, right ), senior principal member of technical staff at AT&T, described an ISAC demonstration with Ericsson in the US state of Texas several months ago, in which multistatic sensing located and tracked several drones. A system built for communication was doing a radar’s work, with AI at the site filtering clutter, but he noted “it takes a lot of resources”. Turning the technology into a new source of revenue “needs to be looked into very carefully”, he added. Steve Papa ( pictured, second from right ), CEO of Parallel Wireless, said multistatic sensing lowers the cost per node but makes timing critical, so his company is trying to build the first nanosecond-synchronised cluster of sites. Looking up for drones is a different problem from looking down, because cell antennas tilt towards the ground. There are also issues around waveforms which need to be worked out. Fox said OFDM goes blind in high-mobility, high-Doppler conditions, and the department is funding tests of alternatives with Cohere Technologies . Amitav Mukherjee ( pictured, third from left ), CEO of Tiami Networks, counselled restraint. “Use the energy that’s already there in the environment,” he said. In his view, OFDM-based sensing works as an early detection system, with other sensors brought in when more precision is needed. ISAC takes shape Mukherjee said tying ISAC to autonomous systems is the fastest route to revenue, because “you cannot wait for a human to step in and tell your delivery drone where to go.” His company’s platform, which he described as a multi-modal world foundation model which detects changes and predicts events, is aimed at fleets of delivery robots and drones, where every human intervention costs the operator money. In simulations, he said, it can cut the time or number of interventions by up to 30%. Keysight’s Sundhar made a similar point, saying micro-Doppler variations and trajectory data can feed models which predict what a target will do next. By Papa’s count, US operators have around 35 million analog-to-digital converters (ADCs) live in their radios which could give them spectrum awareness. “You’ve got all these millions of ADCs. You have hundreds of millions on the device side,” Mukherjee said. “These are additional ADCs that could be used for sensing as well.” Standards are also progressing. Mohajeri said ISAC is enabled in 5G-Advanced, with the northbound exposure API roughly 75% defined and a specification due by March. It’s also expected to be a key element of 3GPP 6G specifications, but Papa was more critical of the process: “We can’t trust the 3GPP to get this right,” he said. Operator game plan To offer sensing as a service, Mohajeri said an operator needs an exposure layer which authenticates requests, plus a new sensing function in the packet core which turns each request into instructions for the right radios. It also needs to decide whether the service is always on, since sensing takes capacity away from communications, and work out roaming and the sensing of people who are not its subscribers. As for monetising ISAC, Papa said he as